I am very grateful for the work of Ben Corey. His blog is one that I frequently read and often find myself “liking” his posts on Facebook. I found his book Undiluted to be challenging, well-written and all around fantastic. And his podcast, That God Show, with Matthew Paul Turner is fun and interesting.
So I was surprised to find myself disappointed with his recent post calling on people to flee from Calvinism. To be clear – I am not a Calvinist. If anything I am probably quite close to Corey in my theology. I have many issues with much theology that goes by the name Calvinism, which I will not get into here. But I also realize that “Calvinism” is a blanket term that covers a lot of people and movements.
For Corey to say you ought to flee from “Calvinism” because some segments, specifically those in the “young, restless and reformed” world, are damaging seems overly simplistic. Ought we do the same to any other group? Would Corey be okay with a warning to flee Anabaptism due to a few examples on the worst side of it? Do we jettison Christianity as a whole because of a few segments that are awful?
To be fair, the sort of Calvinism that Corey seems to be targeting, which has been labelled is the most vocal in the evangelical world right now. It is easy to equate all Calvinism with these so-called New Calvinists. That said, a writer of Corey’s stature, someone pursuing a doctoral decree, owes more to the Christian community.
While I am not a Calvinist, I have been greatly blessed by the work of many Calvinists. Whatever you think of Calvinism, there is much good in there.
1. Marilynne Robinson – She’s one of the best novelists living today and her books of essays, such as When I Was a Child I Read Books, are fantastic. If you haven’t read Gilead and its sequels you must.
2. James K.A. Smith – He has become one of my favorite authors and his books have a ton to offer, from summarizing the work of Catholic philosopher Charles Taylor to a slightly different (or at least not well-known enough) spin on Calvinism.
3. John Bunyan – Pilgrim’s Progress is a classic that all Christians should read.
4. John Newton – Once a slave trader, ended up being one of the first to speak out against that evil. Greatly influenced Wilberforce and is most known for the hymn Amazing Grace.
5. Tim Keller – His books and sermons illustrate how a pastor can also be a thoughtful theologian and apologist; the success of his church in NY city is impressive. His book The Reason for God is still my favorite apologetic work.
6. Alvin Plantinga – He is probably the top living Christian philosopher. His works are demanding, the few I have read have made my brain hurt. Any Christian would benefit from wrestling with his work. I hope to finally read his book, Where the Conflict Really Lies: Science, Religion and Naturalism, this summer.
7. John Calvin – The man who started it all! I read his classic work The Institutes of Christian Religion a few years back. There were times I got so mad I wanted to throw it across the room! But I also found it encouraging and challenging. Of all the Christian “classics” I have read, I was most impressed by the style of writing. This book was clearly written for normal people to read and learn from.
8. Pine Springs Camp – Moving from writers, I worked at this camp in Western PA for two summers in college. It was one of the most influential and life-shaping experiences of my life. Had I “fled” from the Calvinism of this place, I would have been the one at loss. It was also here that I first learned what Calvinism was, being introduced to TULIP, which I thought was nuts. But in the midst of disagreement, lots of good was done. The number of individual persons here whose life and work impacted me would be too long to list.
9. Jubilee – I never attended this conference for college students while in college, but I have taken students there. I can’t say it is the best conference for college students, but it is fantastic and unique. The focus is not, like so many conferences, on just getting kids fired up for Jesus. Instead the focus is helping them think through their major and career in relationship with their faith.